Is England the least patriotic nation in the world? Why is flying a St. George’s flag seen as racist?
Tom Puddy calls for the English to be proud, fly St. George's flag and embrace patriotism - and how we should stop assuming that someone flying a Saint George’s flag outside of a sports match must be a racist.

For some reason that I’ve never understood, Englishmen and women seem to have an inherent fear of showing patriotism. It’s not exactly like we’re lacking things of which to be proud. England has some of the most beautiful landscapes and sights in the world, with glorious architecture and wonderful countryside. England has fought against and brought down tyrants and conquerors and has for centuries been a haven for those that have needed one. England has sired some the greatest geniuses, artists, scientists, writers, composers, explorers, engineers, politicians, philosophers, mathematicians, musicians, and heroes of all time, and has conquered pretty much every profession there is going. England’s history is fascinating and while there are blemishes, I defy anyone who doesn’t see England’s legacy as one which has made the world a better place.

Outside of the UK the Irish have a day of national pride that has swept the globe and is loved by drinkers everywhere.
I was always tempted to believe that it was British understatement; that we British don’t exhibit our nationality in the same vulgar way that other countries do. But it doesn’t take long to see that this isn’t the case. On Saint David’s day entire fields of daffodils suddenly spring up on Welsh lapels, and when the rugby’s on it is striking how many people suddenly remember that their great-grandmothers were half Welsh. Meanwhile the Scots have always been wonderfully proud of their identity and homeland; so much so that they now have a political party based on a policy not seen since the emperor Hadrian. Across the water you can see a healing Northern Ireland that is heading towards the better, with a new pride forming out of today’s stability. Outside of the UK the Irish have a day of national pride that has swept the globe and is loved by drinkers everywhere. Even the French out do us in showing their national pride, and quite frankly there’s a lot less for them to be proud of.

‘Disraeli for example almost exclusively relied on the term “English” when referring to Britain’
Why then are the English against showing feelings of patriotism? My inner optimist would like to believe the argument that it’s a matter of semantics. For centuries the words English and British were interchangeable. Disraeli for example almost exclusively relied on the term “English” when referring to Britain, and when Napoleon said that “[t]wo powers like France and England, with a good understanding between them, might govern the world”, he didn’t envisage that good relations should cease west of the Severn. Yet the desire for devolution has caused this old definition to become out of date. Scots and Welsh no longer fall under the definition of “English” and some dislike the idea of even being “British”. In effect their desire to re-establish their own national identities has been the act of splitting from England in a manner which has left the English lagging behind. The English have been left in a position where it is no longer clear as to how they ought to identify themselves, whether they ought to use the inclusive and unionist term “British” or to utilise their own individual identity as “English”. The result being that the English are theoretically uncertain as to whether they ought to be flying the Union flag, or the flag of Saint George, so fly neither.

‘Understandably, people do not want to be seen to be condoning groups like the BNP or EDL’
More pessimistically, and probably a greater contributor for this lack of patriotism lies in extremism. Understandably, people do not want to be seen to be condoning groups like the BNP or EDL. These two dangerous and racist groups claim that their message of hate is somehow linked to patriotism. It isn’t. Ever since they took the Union flag and flag of Saint George as emblems for their own odious agendas, a fear of guilt by association has arisen. This is a huge pity, both for those living in England and English society as a whole as it detracts from the sort of unity that that this country used to enjoy, and which other countries still enjoy today. The racism of thugs has nothing to do with patriotism.
Real patriotism is a shared sense of national personality. It is pride in the heritage and cultural history of your country. It’s an appreciation of your nation’s environment and sights, both its natural beauty and its inspiring man-made structures. Patriotism is being part of not just the community around you, but of institutions and achievements which might be hundreds of years old. It’s the celebration of who you are and where you call home. It’s an appreciation of your own identity and yet also a feeling of kinship. It is in fact one of the best, most selfless and noblest things a person can feel.

We should stop assuming that someone flying a Saint George’s flag outside of a sports match must be a racist.
Oscar Wilde is attributed as having said that “patriotism is a virtue of the vicious”. If he actually said that, then he was wrong. And so too are all the people who jump to the assumption that someone flying a Saint George’s flag outside of a sports match must be racist. Not only is proper English patriotism something that people ought to show proudly, it would also greatly deflate any arguments that racist groups may have. So long as flying the flag is seen as taboo by the chattering classes and automatically dismissed as the act of a racist or a lunatic, those who want to show their patriotism will always feel alienated.
But I would go further than that. I don’t just think that we should be more tolerant of patriotism; I think that on the whole the English ought to embrace it. So my suggestion for this summer is to really get involved. The Queen’s Diamond Jubilee and the London Olympics both promise to be staggeringly good events, and as ever there’s a myriad of other events throughout the year for people to not just feel proud of their nation, but to show off the fact too. I say, go out there, fly the flags and make the absolute most of a wonderful time.


8:08 pm 10th May, 2012
Interesting article, but I feel patriotism and the lack of it in England is a non-issue. Patriotism simply means a devotion to one’s country, and is entirely different to having a sense of pride in common heritage and cultural history.
A great first article! Whilst we may not agree on certain issues I’m always interested in reading about people’s different points of views.
1:28 pm 12th May, 2012
Cheers, really appreciated. I think that you’re wrong about how different the terms patriotism and national pride are. To feel devotion or to support your country is indeed patriotism, but it stems from the pride you feel in you country. Patriotism is more than the act of giving your country you support and it has a long going for it.
As for your point about it being a non-issue. I would say that you’re right in the sense that it has less of a dramatic impact than for example job losses, but that doesn’t mean that it’s not important. Many people these days feel alienated and unsure as to how to act regarding their own country. No matter what, that’s sad. The really awful part is that it can also drive people into the arms of extremist demagogues.
9:31 pm 10th May, 2012
The problem with patriots is they never content themselves with loving the British countryside or admiring our people and our achievements, they always want to dictate an adherence to an unblinking unthinking uncritical acceptance, even a glorification, of our State. Fuck that shit. The historical truth is clear for anyone with eyes to see and a brain to understand, the British State was and continues to be involved in too much bad, racist, exploitative, murderous shit in all our names, and none of us who love our country should feel remotely obliged to sign up. Is the UK great? Sure, we’re fucking brilliant! Have our governments ever remotely lived up to that? Occasionally perhaps, but not often.
2:19 pm 11th May, 2012
And therein lies the problem. For some reason, certain people don’t seem able to distinguish between patriotism (a love of one’s country) and nationalism (seeing one’s country as superior to another). Patriots don’t want uncriticical acceptance and glorification of the state – in fact it seems to be socialists, the defenders against the ‘evils’ of patriotism, that preach starry-eyed devotion to the state. It is insulting for a patriot of any political hue to tied into the actions of the British state. Oh, and since the definition of a patriot is “One who loves, supports, and defends one’s country” and you believe the UK to be, in your words, “fucking brilliant”, that makes you a patriot
11:24 pm 10th May, 2012
”Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.” – Samuel Johnson
”In Dr. Johnson’s famous dictionary patriotism is defined as the last resort of a scoundrel. With all due respect to an enlightened but inferior lexicographer, I beg to submit that it is the first.” – Ambrose Bierce
5:04 pm 10th May, 2012
Great a article and absolutely spot on. Let’s start by having St. Georges day a designated bank holiday, that would get the ball rolling and give us an outlet to officially proclaim our patriotism which I think would go a long way to making us patriotic again.
2:02 am 13th May, 2012
Hear hear!
5:06 pm 10th May, 2012
I hope so, patriotism is just fluffed up ignorance.
2:02 am 13th May, 2012
You’re basing this on what?
4:35 pm 14th May, 2012
People like you.
7:32 pm 10th May, 2012
Well seing how the Diamond Jubilee went, I’d say Britain is one of the most patriotic country in the world…